“Children of this World” by Ellen F. Pinsent, (Methuen & Co.): The heroine of this in many ways clever though terribly depressing story does not by precept or example attach the tottering institution of marriage. She demolishes Christianity, for a change, in various conversations and in a magazine article, and the moral of the book is that the only alternative to infidelity is submission to the authority of the Romish Church, one of those easily formulated propositions at which lady novelists are apt to jump and take for fundamental and indisputable truths. But the agnostic pro paganism is pretty well subordinated to the presentation of human passions and actions. Janet, who is a Newnham girl with views, is an interesting character, and her relations with her lovers, especially with Ralph, who leaves the Church all for lover of her, but loses her in the end, are described with genuine power and truthfulness, though there is surely something wrong about the hint of a happy marriage with which the story closes. Even more interesting than Janet is her pious, believing, mystical friend Rachel, also a Newnham girl, who brought up in a lower middle-class Dissenting household, took to the Church, and found herself entirely out of sympathy with her surroundings, which, both in their religious and their social aspects, are capitally described though we doubt if her conduct towards her married lover was altogether natural, while he himself is a rather flabby creation, and we do not get a very clear or distinct idea of his personality. Surely, too, in ordinary society his marriage with Kitty, who is charming in her way, would have been postponed till he had got something definite to do; but, of course, in that case he would not have flirted with poor Rachel in the same perilous fashion, and in these days no novel can be regarded as complete even though Christianity is attacked in it, without the dramatic element of post-matrimonial love for a former flame or for a new one. We have not been able quite to make out who the children of this work are, but that does not matter and the story, though there is too much chatter in it, has many good points.
Transcribed in whole or part from scanned originals: Presented with or without modified text and punctuation. For absolute accuracy refer to the original newspapers. Source: The British Newspaper Archive.
Referenced
GRO0245 Devonport: Ellen Frances Parker: 1866 – 1949